You lucky guys who get to track and mix really good experienced studio drummers...
what sort of consistency are you seeing in terms of
A) snare volume changes (not talking about intentional changes, e.g. verse v chorus etc But when its a basic snare part , what in terms of dB fluctuation are you seeing.
B) consistency of tone, I guess due to accuracy of the snare hitting in the intended spot of the drum and developing the same tone.
Interested in your thoughts...
eg
during a normal verse, hits wouldnt vary by more than 1 to 2dB, and sound should be almost perfect.
Why am I thinking about this, well, I was thinking about drum replacement with samples, and the (perhaps) unrealistic world of snare drum playing it may have imposed on music.
Also, my question goes then to compression amounts and threshold...
cheers
Wiz
- It is currently Mon May 20, 2024 2:26 am • All times are UTC + 10 hours [ DST ]
snare consistency.
Moderators: ChrisW, rick, Mark Bassett
12 posts
• Page 1 of 1
snare consistency.
Peter Knight
Cant ego loquemur Latine
http://www.peterknightmusician.com
Cant ego loquemur Latine
http://www.peterknightmusician.com
- Wiz
- Valued Contributor
- Posts: 1147
- Joined: Thu Dec 03, 2009 10:17 pm
Re: snare consistency.
I always shoot for complete consistency of tone and volume.
It's hard to determine a difference of 5db with the naked ear.
The number one consistent volume drum in my playing is the bass drum.
Snare can be a mix of lighter hits and harder hits, but if there is a backbeat I will play it with the same tone and as close to the same volume as I can.
Hi hats add groove with lots of lighter and accented notes.
While sounding consistent, my drum hits may vary by more than 5db, but you can't really hear it. When we are sampling drums for Toontrack we try to play repeated hits 1 or 2db apart, but it's virtually impossible except by luck.
Regarding compression, I like to think my drum tracks need no compression as a fix. When using a drum sample library you should need no compression either. One can add compression as a matter of taste, for effect, but not to fix inconsistent dynamics.
The problem with the virtual drum libraries is that most people use them in the higher velocities (120 to 127).
It's like a bricklayer icing a cake.
Velocities 100 to 120 sound more natural. Unfortunately, a lot of the supplied midi grooves are also in the 120 to 127 range. It's like a virtual drum library loudness war.
It's hard to determine a difference of 5db with the naked ear.
The number one consistent volume drum in my playing is the bass drum.
Snare can be a mix of lighter hits and harder hits, but if there is a backbeat I will play it with the same tone and as close to the same volume as I can.
Hi hats add groove with lots of lighter and accented notes.
While sounding consistent, my drum hits may vary by more than 5db, but you can't really hear it. When we are sampling drums for Toontrack we try to play repeated hits 1 or 2db apart, but it's virtually impossible except by luck.
Regarding compression, I like to think my drum tracks need no compression as a fix. When using a drum sample library you should need no compression either. One can add compression as a matter of taste, for effect, but not to fix inconsistent dynamics.
The problem with the virtual drum libraries is that most people use them in the higher velocities (120 to 127).
It's like a bricklayer icing a cake.
Velocities 100 to 120 sound more natural. Unfortunately, a lot of the supplied midi grooves are also in the 120 to 127 range. It's like a virtual drum library loudness war.
Whitten
- ChrisW
- Valued Contributor
- Posts: 1285
- Joined: Thu Jan 29, 2009 12:01 pm
- Location: Hunter
Re: snare consistency.
ChrisW wrote:I always shoot for complete consistency of tone and volume.
It's hard to determine a difference of 5db with the naked ear.
The number one consistent volume drum in my playing is the bass drum.
Snare can be a mix of lighter hits and harder hits, but if there is a backbeat I will play it with the same tone and as close to the same volume as I can.
Hi hats add groove with lots of lighter and accented notes.
While sounding consistent, my drum hits may vary by more than 5db, but you can't really hear it. When we are sampling drums for Toontrack we try to play repeated hits 1 or 2db apart, but it's virtually impossible except by luck.
Regarding compression, I like to think my drum tracks need no compression as a fix. When using a drum sample library you should need no compression either. One can add compression as a matter of taste, for effect, but not to fix inconsistent dynamics.
The problem with the virtual drum libraries is that most people use them in the higher velocities (120 to 127).
It's like a bricklayer icing a cake.
Velocities 100 to 120 sound more natural. Unfortunately, a lot of the supplied midi grooves are also in the 120 to 127 range. It's like a virtual drum library loudness war.
Chris
thanks so much for the reply... is just the info I was seeking
cheers
Wiz
Peter Knight
Cant ego loquemur Latine
http://www.peterknightmusician.com
Cant ego loquemur Latine
http://www.peterknightmusician.com
- Wiz
- Valued Contributor
- Posts: 1147
- Joined: Thu Dec 03, 2009 10:17 pm
Re: snare consistency.
i actually don't like it being too consistent!
im not doing straight pop stuff though…
but i do like to "perceive" or feel a change in beats here and there
it makes it feel real to me
when its too solid i actually don't like it and end up fiddling around!
i do comp my snare pretty hard though (usually a little on the way in with a 160, and more in the mix with either a 160 again or maybe a distressor, then usually something across the whole drum buss - either ditressors or drawer 1960)
so after all that its the tone that shifts (by hitting the comps) more than the actual level.
im not doing straight pop stuff though…
but i do like to "perceive" or feel a change in beats here and there
it makes it feel real to me
when its too solid i actually don't like it and end up fiddling around!
i do comp my snare pretty hard though (usually a little on the way in with a 160, and more in the mix with either a 160 again or maybe a distressor, then usually something across the whole drum buss - either ditressors or drawer 1960)
so after all that its the tone that shifts (by hitting the comps) more than the actual level.
Gareth Stuckey
gigpiglet productions:presents:recordings
gigpiglet productions:presents:recordings
- gigpiglet
- Valued Contributor
- Posts: 1153
- Joined: Tue Jun 01, 2010 4:10 pm
- Location: sydney australia
Re: snare consistency.
In my world snare hitting consistency, both tone and volume, is super rare.
Kick level consistency is even rarer, and far more annoying when you need it and can't get it.
I don't replace or supplement drums with samples. Or haven't had to yet, I should say.
I am working on mixes at the moment where I have had to apply a brick wall limiter, a multi band limiter acting only on the 3k to 10k range and a final outboard limiter to bring back some tone and front to the kick drum, in addition to the drum being recorded through a very capable compressor.
All of this just to get consistent level and tone. Not to sound effected.
Cheers,
Paul
Kick level consistency is even rarer, and far more annoying when you need it and can't get it.
I don't replace or supplement drums with samples. Or haven't had to yet, I should say.
I am working on mixes at the moment where I have had to apply a brick wall limiter, a multi band limiter acting only on the 3k to 10k range and a final outboard limiter to bring back some tone and front to the kick drum, in addition to the drum being recorded through a very capable compressor.
All of this just to get consistent level and tone. Not to sound effected.
Cheers,
Paul
- Paul Maybury
- Frequent Contributor
- Posts: 705
- Joined: Tue Nov 17, 2009 3:07 pm
- Location: Melbourne
Re: snare consistency.
I would much prefer consistency of tone - than volume.
Its all about hitting the sweet spot.
Ive nearly completely stopped using any compression at all on snare, I love snare dynamics - same as not squashing a mix with a bus comp, in mixing or mastering.
So I get around level inconsistencies by volume rides on the odd too loud/quiet hits.
Just finished an album mixing on Chris V's killer Neve -) not a comp on any snare track.
(but I do like a bit on kick so it locks in velocity with the bass)
So Ive done the full circle, 5-10 -20 years ago i would reach for a snare comp on the majority of albums, now its rare. My mixes are much better for the restraint.
I will never track with a snare comp anymore, as it alters the tone and spill in various ways that can't be undone.
Level is really easy to deal with.
But snare tone - I hunt for it, and at times have to blend a replaced snare in with the real one to get tonal consistency if the drummer does not know where to hit the damn thing to make it sing.
Sometimes I even have to draw a circle on the snare with a texta to remind a drummer to focus on the sweet spot(s).
To my ears, music is dynamic -> mixing ditto -> listening ditto.
Its all about hitting the sweet spot.
Ive nearly completely stopped using any compression at all on snare, I love snare dynamics - same as not squashing a mix with a bus comp, in mixing or mastering.
So I get around level inconsistencies by volume rides on the odd too loud/quiet hits.
Just finished an album mixing on Chris V's killer Neve -) not a comp on any snare track.
(but I do like a bit on kick so it locks in velocity with the bass)
So Ive done the full circle, 5-10 -20 years ago i would reach for a snare comp on the majority of albums, now its rare. My mixes are much better for the restraint.
I will never track with a snare comp anymore, as it alters the tone and spill in various ways that can't be undone.
Level is really easy to deal with.
But snare tone - I hunt for it, and at times have to blend a replaced snare in with the real one to get tonal consistency if the drummer does not know where to hit the damn thing to make it sing.
Sometimes I even have to draw a circle on the snare with a texta to remind a drummer to focus on the sweet spot(s).
To my ears, music is dynamic -> mixing ditto -> listening ditto.
C h r i z t o w n o
- The Tasmanian
- Valued Contributor
- Posts: 1901
- Joined: Thu Nov 27, 2008 8:04 am
- Location: Deep in the woods....
Re: snare consistency.
> I'm available <
Anyway…..
As a drummer I would prefer to hear a supporting sample, helping consistency of velocity and tone, than to have my drums processed to hell and double compressed.
Anyway…..
As a drummer I would prefer to hear a supporting sample, helping consistency of velocity and tone, than to have my drums processed to hell and double compressed.
Whitten
- ChrisW
- Valued Contributor
- Posts: 1285
- Joined: Thu Jan 29, 2009 12:01 pm
- Location: Hunter
Re: snare consistency.
Been great replies!
Thanks, it really helped.
I found by instantiating a gain plug in first in my effects chain, then, doing automation to take care of most of the inconsistency, I got where I wanted to go.
I used a hair of sample replacement, and a tiny, tiny bit of 1176 compression prior to the sample replacement and I am good.
cheers
Wiz
Thanks, it really helped.
I found by instantiating a gain plug in first in my effects chain, then, doing automation to take care of most of the inconsistency, I got where I wanted to go.
I used a hair of sample replacement, and a tiny, tiny bit of 1176 compression prior to the sample replacement and I am good.
cheers
Wiz
Peter Knight
Cant ego loquemur Latine
http://www.peterknightmusician.com
Cant ego loquemur Latine
http://www.peterknightmusician.com
- Wiz
- Valued Contributor
- Posts: 1147
- Joined: Thu Dec 03, 2009 10:17 pm
Re: snare consistency.
ChrisW wrote:> I'm available <
> Me too <
But, unlike Chris, I can test your engineering skills in the use of compression to the limit
Ian Dare
- Drumstruck
- Valued Contributor
- Posts: 1589
- Joined: Fri Sep 17, 2010 12:37 pm
- Location: NSW South Coast
Re: snare consistency.
Well, last night I had the pleasure of mixing drums that didn't need any help. That is how I'd prefer things to be.
Cheers,
Paul
Cheers,
Paul
- Paul Maybury
- Frequent Contributor
- Posts: 705
- Joined: Tue Nov 17, 2009 3:07 pm
- Location: Melbourne
Re: snare consistency.
Use a great drummer. In my case Danny Heifetz. Wow, like a (tasteful) machine. Tell him once and out it comes the next take. Grace pace and space.
Electronics never any substitute for great playing.
Electronics never any substitute for great playing.
- number1son
- Registered User
- Posts: 23
- Joined: Tue Aug 02, 2011 11:11 pm
Re: snare consistency.
Back in the drum machine days (remember them?), when they started sounding pretty good (around the time of the Roland R8 I reckon) the dead giveaway was always consistency of level (modern drum libraries/virtual drummers are of course much more dynamic).
I owned a lot of drum machines during the 80s and 90s!
I owned a lot of drum machines during the 80s and 90s!
wez prictor
composure music
http://www.composuremusic.com.au/
Australian importer of Crumar Mojo keyboards & accessories. Vintage keyboard fetishist.
composure music
http://www.composuremusic.com.au/
Australian importer of Crumar Mojo keyboards & accessories. Vintage keyboard fetishist.
-
wez - Valued Contributor
- Posts: 1259
- Joined: Fri May 06, 2005 10:38 pm
- Location: Slightly to the left.
12 posts
• Page 1 of 1
Who is online
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 1 guest