Arcane? Sure, insofar as there are few "mysteries" anymore. But demystification is not knowledge, and knowledge is not experience.
I'm pretty sure it's the same "art" as it's always been. I suspect it's our standards that have changed. Many people just want to "do vinyl" - they don't actually care that much about the sonic result, just as long as it looks good on the merch stand.
waitup wrote:Ehem, unless of course the record/mix/master guy successfuly makes vinyl masters all the time, has the tools to do so and knows what they're doing...
Exactly as I said... someone who's done it a lot and knows what they are doing. But I'm wary of the multitude of jack-of-all-trades types desperate to cling on to a client for as much of the process as they can, even when it's not in the client's best interest. Genuine audio polymaths are a very rare breed. Those who "specialise" in everything are - by definition - not specialists. And I stand by my assertion that mastering for vinyl is a specialist skill, whilst acknowledging that not everyone has the same standards or expectations.
It's very easy to know a few things, and not too hard to work out what you don't know. It's what you don't know you don't know that will trip you up.